Dear All,
And so it comes to the writing of the coursework!
Please do not name your work so that you feel comfortable when you publish it on our blog.
Type out the title on the Word document so that the reader knows what question you are answering.
Write the introduction on the Word document and then paste it in the commentary box.
Remember that you must 'un-pick' the question by using all the key words in the title and reference them in some way in the introduction. Look at the 5 sample essays I have given you. Look at your version of the plan that the students might have used to ensure that they are addressing the significant aspects of the title. You must consider all the key words to ensure that you are covering all aspects of the question and all Assessment Objectives. Try to use a clever quotation from the play or from a critic which focuses on the debate built into your title. Make sure that you consider both sides of the argument established in your question to hit A03.
Continue writing the next paragraph of your essay while you are waiting for your class mates to publish their introduction.
Remember that each new paragraph needs to start with a TOPIC SENTENCE which relates back to the title and will use one of the key words or ideas. You will need to make clear which side of the debate you are considering so that you clearly show later on in your essay that you are then considering a different interpretation AO3.
It is essential that you closely analyse your chosen scenes so that you are covering AO2-analysis and evaluation of language, structure and form. Many candidates avoid or only briefly mention structural points because they think referencing structure is difficult. You must mention structural points whether they are within a line, a scene or an act! Openings and endings and exits and entrances are very important for structure and form (it is a play to be performed in front of an audience). Do use the link to the recording of the 2007 RSC performance of Lear in the Student Shared Area, then you can mention how the Director Trevor Nunn and the Producer Richard Price interpreted and presented the play.
Keep checking the blog and read the group's introductions. Please add a line of praise and a line of advice but do make your comments relevant o how well each person is hitting AO1, AO2, AO3 and AO4.
THE BEST WAY TO GET BETTER AT WRITING IS BY WRITING!
One can argue that Lear’s tragic downfall is the result of the pride he shows not only towards himself but to those who he loved most. In this play Shakespeare follows the Senecan structure of writing a tragedy, taking up a five act form; signifying the play will be of some tragic genre. Act 1 Scene 1 is an excellent example of pride taking over and leading to destruction, disaster and in the end, Lear’s downfall. The pride he takes in himself, demanding his daughters express their love for him “Which of you shall we say doth love us most”, results in him splitting the country between the “loving” daughters. However, if the pride initially shown towards his daughters didn’t happen, it is unlikely the characters around him would have contributed to his downfall so much. However they do, as apparent in Act 2 Scene 4 where Lear is sent to live with Regan, but with only 25 of 100 knights. This detrimental move by the sisters now means Lear is left powerless as an isolated old man. This part is significant as it shows a scheming, evil side to his daughters who seemed to of recognised how they will defeat Lear; showing the audience his tragic downfall is contributed to by the characters around him.
ReplyDeleteImprovement- You should try include something about Aristotle's theory as it links into King Lear's downfall.(hubris+hamartia)
ReplyDeleteTo what extent does the tragic unifying theme of blindness create sympathy for the tragic victims, Lear and Gloucester, in the play?
ReplyDelete(Consider Lear’s symbolic blindness at the beginning of the play and Gloucester’s violent blinding at the end.)
Blindness is a main theme in King Lear, in the sense that it is both Lear and Gloucester’s hamartia, leading ultimately to their deaths. In Lear’s case, he is metaphorically blind to the personalities and honesty of his daughters, driven by his ego to doubt Cordelia while he trusts Regan and Goneril, who eventually betray him. Gloucester, paralleling Lear, is blind to the feelings of his two sons, Edmund, who is illegitimate, and Edgar. This results in his literal blinding and also his death. The use of blindness as a moral of the play is very effective as it allows the audience to question whether or not their demise was actually Lear or Gloucester’s fault. This consequently allows the audience to sympathise with the tragic victims as their actions were not done out of malice, but out of blindness. However this blindness may be taken as a fault of the characters, worthy of the punishments they were dealt, therefore not evoking as much sympathy as if Lear and Gloucester are considered good characters.
The unifying theme of King Lear is that of blindness. The older generation's inability to see clearly explains the tragic outcomes of the play.' To what extent do you agree with this statement?
ReplyDeleteTypically in Shakespearian tragedy, a characters downfall is partly of their own making; in Shakespeare’s King Lear physical blindness cannot be a character’s hubris. Therefore the question is referring to metaphorical blindness, how Lear cannot see past the lies of his dishonest daughters for example. For a theme to be “unifying,” it must be present throughout the play, and in tragedy specifically at the points of catharsis. It must also be a catalyst for unfolding events, in this case the decent into chaos of Lear’s kingdom. In addition to be “the unifying” theme it must fulfil these criteria to a greater extent than any other. This essay will examine whether this can be said of “blindness.”
'To what extent is Lear’s tragic downfall a result of his pride, blindness or the actions of other characters around him? Consider different interpretations of the character King Lear and write about how you would respond to it. (focusing on Act 1 Scene 1, Act 3 Scene 2, Act 2 Scene 1 and Act 5 Scene 3'. One may argue that Lear’s own hamartia is his outstanding inability to ignore the manipulative behaviour of characters around him. In Act 1 Scene 1, we see Goneril and Regan using bogus moments of compassion to inherit their father’s kingdom, claiming he is ‘dearer than eyesight.’ Blind to this, Lear banishes his genuine, deeply-loving daughter Cordelia as a result of pride taking over reality; proving the definitive quality of ‘a tragic hero enjoying prosperity and a high reputation’ as told by Aristotle. Lear’s downfall throughout the first act of the tragedy proceeds to a manifest of madness and chaos and appalling inhumanity by Act 3. The playwright’s recipe of scheming characters and self-provoked inner turmoil culminates into Lear’s deterioration from a position of power but also his own humanity as a father and a person.
ReplyDeleteSome readers and audiences think that Lear is responsible for the chaos, disorder and reversals of fortune within the tragedy; others believe that outside forces are ranged too strongly against him.
ReplyDeleteConsider these interpretations of ‘King Lear’ and write about how you would respond to it.
The play 'King Lear', by William Shakespeare, like many of the tragic plays written at that time, appears to have a universal theme of chaos, disorder and reversals in fortune. The unusual element of ‘King Lear’, however, is the idea that there is no sole being blamed for the tragic outcomes of the play. This is idea is relevant when comparing the morals of 17th Century England, and their feelings towards natural order and position of power, and how even the original audience of the time may have been divided on the argument. Many readers and audiences agree that Lear himself is responsible for the fate of the play, as the ‘arrogant’ King hands his kingdom to his two scheming daughters, while banishing his only kind daughter. This mistake is said to have sparked a chain of events consequently leading to tragic ending of the play. This mistake may be the result of Lear’s tragic flaw, which has also be debated, with critic John Cunningham stating that Lear’s only fault is his ‘honesty’, but it could also be the result of many other forces working against him. Many have considered this idea, and it is said that these forces could perhaps be the scheming of Goneril and Regan, the strength of nature or perhaps even just fate itself.
King Lear is a tragedy about both political and domestic discord. How far do you agree that Shakespeare presents Lear’s tragic fall as rooted in his failure as a ruler, or as a father?
ReplyDeleteOver the course of Shakespeare’s King Lear, the absolute power of the eponymous character brings about his tragic down fall through the disowning of his honest daughter Cordelia and the events that follow. While this directly relates to his ignorance of his daughters’ true nature, it can also be argued that his position as King causes his original hubris of vanity and egotism, leading to his fatal hamartia. Lear’s flaw of character in both of these roles is made evident in the language used between characters in Act 1 Scene 1, which conveys his lack of clear vision towards his daughters. The structure of the play similarly highlights Lear’s position as both a ruler and a father, with each act displaying his further descent into tragedy and insanity, while creating parallels between himself and Gloucester as fathers. The pathos and catharsis experienced by the audience in Act 5 Scene 3, caused by Lear’s increasingly wild and disjointed speech over the death of his daughters, additionally draws the focus to his loss of power as a ruler and his grief as a father. While there are aspects of hope at the play’s conclusion, Lear’s actions have lost him authority over both his children and his citizens.